Home › Insurance & Costs › What Not to Say to an Adjuster

What Not to Say to Your Adjuster — From People Who Were Adjusters

Why this page exists

Most water-damage advice online is written by people who've never sat on the insurance side of the table. The Maven Mitigation crew has — 20+ years in insurance adjusting, public adjusting, and FEMA deployments. So we know something homeowners usually learn the hard way: how you describe your loss to the insurer can matter as much as the loss itself. Not because you should ever lie — you shouldn't — but because volunteering the wrong framing hands the adjuster reasons to narrow or deny a claim that was genuinely covered.

The word that flags a claim: "mold"

Here's the one that costs people. The moment you say "mold," many carriers mentally reclassify your claim. Why? Because mold is associated with long-term, gradual moisture — and no standard policy covers long-term damage. Say "I think there's mold" and the claim can get flagged as a possible denial before an adjuster has even seen the facts.

The honest, accurate alternative is to lead with the sudden event: "A supply line burst and flooded the bathroom. I shut off the water and called for extraction the same day." If mold is present, it gets handled as a consequence of a covered sudden loss that you addressed promptly — which is exactly what fast, documented drying establishes.

What not to say (and what to say instead)

• Don't say: "It's been leaking for a while." → Say: "I discovered it today when I saw the ceiling stain."
• Don't say: "I think it's mold." → Say: "There's water damage from the burst pipe; the mitigation company is documenting moisture levels."
• Don't say: "It's probably my fault, I should've replaced that." → Say: "The connector failed and released water suddenly."
• Don't say: "How much will you give me?" or accept a number on the spot. → Say: "I'll have the full documentation and estimate for you."
• Don't guess at cause, duration, or dollar figures. Speculation becomes part of the record.

Say only what you know

You are not the claims investigator, and you're not obligated to theorize. Three facts carry a water claim: when you discovered it, what you saw, and what you did to stop it. Everything else — cause determination, scope, cost — is established by evidence, not by your guesses in a stressful moment.

The best thing you can bring: your own documentation

Adjusters work from evidence. The strongest position you can be in is walking into the inspection with:

• Timestamped photos and video of the damage and the source
• The source of loss clearly identified (the failed part, kept if possible — see subrogation)
• Professional moisture readings and drying logs from your mitigation company

That's the documentation we produce from the first visit, in the format adjusters expect — because it's the format we used to work in. It's also what keeps a "sudden" loss from drifting into "gradual" in the file.

What NOT to do

• Don't sign or accept a settlement figure before you have full documentation and an estimate.
• Don't throw away the failed part or the removed materials before the claim is documented.
• Don't delay mitigation to "wait for the adjuster." Your policy expects you to prevent further damage; document, then dry.

If your claim has already been denied, here's what to do next: water damage claim denied.